9. Wait, Who Was That Amy?
On one of their dates, Justin teased her that he had a crush on a girl named Amy in kindergarten. But she had never inquired about that Amy until she noticed a small scar above Justin’s eye. He told her that he had got it from falling off the monkey bars at St Petersburg’s good ol’ Sunshine Preschool. “What? We were in the same class? There must be a mistake.” she thought.